Is the Darwinistic Selection Principle False?

For discussing anything related to physics, biology, chemistry, mathematics, and their practical applications.

Moderator: Flannel Jesus

Is the Darwinistic selection principle false?

Yes.
6
24%
Probably.
4
16%
Perhaps.
0
No votes
No.
14
56%
I do not know.
1
4%
 
Total votes : 25

Re: Is the Darwinistic Selection Principle False?

Postby phoneutria » Wed Jul 22, 2020 11:28 pm

Fixed Cross wrote:Anyone read Dawkins' The Selfish Gene? High quality work.
He argues that it is not the organism but the genes themselves which must be seen as the agent. So you have to look at individual survival and procreation and group survival at once, which changes the logics, and gives another way of looking at "fitness".

So, the group is its own primary environment.


hahaha alright I'll do more than talk shit

in sum...

reading the mentioning of ants and dawkins in the same page is nice, since ants exemplify the idea of the selfish gene pretty well
an ant's only purpose in life is to serve the colony because the colony is them
every single one of them is the exact same genetically

except for the males of course, but not because they are something else, but because they are a reduced version of them
they're fertile, but they hatch from unfertilized eggs
they're the genetic half of what a worker ant is

they're referred to as "flying sperm" sometimes, because that's all they do
they don't even have jaws for eating
they hatch, fly out, mate, and die

it's all controlled by the queen
she deliberately withholds sperm from a small fraction of the eggs she lays so that they remain unfertilized
since they are unfertilized, these eggs contain only her gene

so basically, you get to be fertile, but only because you'll fly out and spread MY gene

anyway, that's why I say we don't act at all like ants
we're not built the same
Last edited by phoneutria on Wed Jul 22, 2020 11:33 pm, edited 2 times in total.
phoneutria
purveyor of enchantment, advocate of pulchritude AND venomously disarming
 
Posts: 3348
Joined: Fri May 23, 2014 5:37 am

Re: Is the Darwinistic Selection Principle False?

Postby phoneutria » Wed Jul 22, 2020 11:30 pm

edit: double post
phoneutria
purveyor of enchantment, advocate of pulchritude AND venomously disarming
 
Posts: 3348
Joined: Fri May 23, 2014 5:37 am

Re: Is the Darwinistic Selection Principle False?

Postby Ecmandu » Wed Jul 22, 2020 11:37 pm

Alright phoneutria,

I’ll give you 1/2 of the debate.

Ants have division of labor. Apes don’t. Ants do farming, apes don’t, ants build cities, apes don’t etc...
Ecmandu
ILP Legend
 
Posts: 10638
Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2014 1:22 am

Re: Is the Darwinistic Selection Principle False?

Postby phoneutria » Thu Jul 23, 2020 3:32 am

ants don't have a central command unit
they're not commanded at all
the queen isn't giving orders
there's no 'obeying' in an ant colony
they're born for a precise function, and they perform it until they die
like the cells in a body, without a will of their own
or rather, they each do have a will, that is the will of the whole
to further the queen's gene, their own gene

there are no depressed ants who wanted to be queens but have to be workers
there's no stealing in an ant colony, no murder
they are a perfect society because they are a single organism

our societies are anything but that
they're just extensions of our clans
the further out you go from the circle of your kin, the more exposed you are
no matter what sets of rules we put in place to keep our mass economics flowing
instinct precedes it all
you fear what is not like you
just watch how apprehensive everyone gets when a pack of young black men walk into a store making a ruckus
we act very much like apes
phoneutria
purveyor of enchantment, advocate of pulchritude AND venomously disarming
 
Posts: 3348
Joined: Fri May 23, 2014 5:37 am

Re: Is the Darwinistic Selection Principle False?

Postby Dan~ » Thu Jul 23, 2020 12:52 pm

phoneutria wrote:you fear what is not like you
just watch how apprehensive everyone gets when a pack of young black men walk into a store making a ruckus
we act very much like apes


People also fear what doesn't equate to their sense of reality.

Ghosts are so scary because they are not a part of our sense of reality.

Impossible things defy theory and can frighten a person.
I like http://www.accuradio.com , internet radio.
https://dannerz.itch.io/ -- a new and minimal webside now hosting two of my free game projects.
Be ware dumbasses that think they are intellectuals.
User avatar
Dan~
ILP Legend
 
Posts: 10249
Joined: Thu Nov 24, 2005 8:14 am
Location: May the loving spirit of papa hitler watch over and bless you all.

Re: Is the Darwinistic Selection Principle False?

Postby Fixed Cross » Thu Jul 23, 2020 4:00 pm

phoneutria wrote:
Fixed Cross wrote:Anyone read Dawkins' The Selfish Gene? High quality work.
He argues that it is not the organism but the genes themselves which must be seen as the agent. So you have to look at individual survival and procreation and group survival at once, which changes the logics, and gives another way of looking at "fitness".

So, the group is its own primary environment.


hahaha alright I'll do more than talk shit

in sum...

reading the mentioning of ants and dawkins in the same page is nice, since ants exemplify the idea of the selfish gene pretty well
an ant's only purpose in life is to serve the colony because the colony is them
every single one of them is the exact same genetically

except for the males of course, but not because they are something else, but because they are a reduced version of them
they're fertile, but they hatch from unfertilized eggs
they're the genetic half of what a worker ant is

they're referred to as "flying sperm" sometimes, because that's all they do
they don't even have jaws for eating
they hatch, fly out, mate, and die

it's all controlled by the queen
she deliberately withholds sperm from a small fraction of the eggs she lays so that they remain unfertilized
since they are unfertilized, these eggs contain only her gene

so basically, you get to be fertile, but only because you'll fly out and spread MY gene

anyway, that's why I say we don't act at all like ants
we're not built the same

Nice little exposition, I appreciate that.

I wasn't considering you an idiot, in the least. I just have no regard for publications as such, so just responded to that reference a bit mockingly. Everyone I know from youth virtually has published papers on this or that, Im from that kind of society.
But most of these are of course things like "city planning" and "social sciences". - Which kind of brings me to a point about ants -
genetically we aren't like ants, but mimetically, woke society and any kind of anonymous mass ideology for that matter, works like you describe the ant world.

Now granted thats technically only a metaphorical relation, but it does work very much along similar lines. Ideological people are simply incapable of existing if they're not entirely dependent for the contents of their self-awareness on some central Ideology which could be considered Queen.
The strong do what they can, the weak accept what they must.
- Thucydides
Image -
valueontologyforsuperIQs - sumofalltemples - The Magical Tree of Life Academy
User avatar
Fixed Cross
Doric Usurper
 
Posts: 10931
Joined: Fri Jul 15, 2011 12:53 am
Location: the black ships

Re: Is the Darwinistic Selection Principle False?

Postby Fixed Cross » Thu Jul 23, 2020 4:13 pm

phoneutria wrote:ants don't have a central command unit
they're not commanded at all
the queen isn't giving orders
there's no 'obeying' in an ant colony
they're born for a precise function, and they perform it until they die
like the cells in a body, without a will of their own
or rather, they each do have a will, that is the will of the whole
to further the queen's gene, their own gene

there are no depressed ants who wanted to be queens but have to be workers
there's no stealing in an ant colony, no murder
they are a perfect society because they are a single organism

our societies are anything but that
they're just extensions of our clans
the further out you go from the circle of your kin, the more exposed you are
no matter what sets of rules we put in place to keep our mass economics flowing
instinct precedes it all
you fear what is not like you
just watch how apprehensive everyone gets when a pack of young black men walk into a store making a ruckus
we act very much like apes

I think its a combination. Humans can kill and expel their kin because of ideals.
Look at the Baghdad Gita, to give a grand example, the battle of Kurukshetra, where people wage war against their own.
The god says that this is how it must happen, that this is where the sprit is forged. In so many words.

The 30 year war in Europe is famous for having come between families.

And so new family lineages are established, based on values........
The strong do what they can, the weak accept what they must.
- Thucydides
Image -
valueontologyforsuperIQs - sumofalltemples - The Magical Tree of Life Academy
User avatar
Fixed Cross
Doric Usurper
 
Posts: 10931
Joined: Fri Jul 15, 2011 12:53 am
Location: the black ships

Re: Is the Darwinistic Selection Principle False?

Postby phoneutria » Thu Jul 23, 2020 7:36 pm

not for nothing that same book introduced the notion of meme
phoneutria
purveyor of enchantment, advocate of pulchritude AND venomously disarming
 
Posts: 3348
Joined: Fri May 23, 2014 5:37 am

Re: Is the Darwinistic Selection Principle False?

Postby phoneutria » Thu Jul 23, 2020 7:37 pm

i mean The Selfish Gene, not Bhagavad Gita
phoneutria
purveyor of enchantment, advocate of pulchritude AND venomously disarming
 
Posts: 3348
Joined: Fri May 23, 2014 5:37 am

Re: Is the Darwinistic Selection Principle False?

Postby Fixed Cross » Thu Jul 23, 2020 11:48 pm

Yes.

A meme thus seen is a representation of value that is real but not organic.
The strong do what they can, the weak accept what they must.
- Thucydides
Image -
valueontologyforsuperIQs - sumofalltemples - The Magical Tree of Life Academy
User avatar
Fixed Cross
Doric Usurper
 
Posts: 10931
Joined: Fri Jul 15, 2011 12:53 am
Location: the black ships

Previous

Return to Science, Technology, and Math



Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users