Uccisore stated:
You first statement is quite correct. That is why I do believe in a higher power, but what that higher power is I am clueless. I just sense that there must be more to our universe than our lonely island called earth. Whether the higher power is a more sophisticated race than ours, or some kind of an all powerful substance, or some kind of ultimate consciousness, is uncertain for me. No religion to date has been able to convince me even slightly that their doctrine is somehow onto something and that their conception of God might be right. That’s why I stay away from the word ‘God’, too many people associate it with a religion. I choose to say I believe in a ‘higher power’. In a way that is agnosticism, but in another way it isn’t cause I am not convinced that there is a God, I just think there is some higher life form other than us, whether it be alien, planet, spirit, ghost, or God him/her/itself. Your statement about Christians is a presumptuous one, you cannot know what each Christian claims about their relationship with God, I have met many Christians and I can’t say that any two of them have the same view of their relationship with God. You barry yourself further by assuming that their relationship with God is DIRECT, if it was direct for all Christians then we would all be Christians and all have the DIRECT line to God. We don’t cause there is no direct line to God. No human being I have ever met has known anything outside of their environment. One can only mix and match experiences, ie. A unicorn, but this is nothing to do with thinking outside of evidence. There is more reason to believe in a unicorn then there is to believe in the Christian God.
Uccisore stated:
Read my previous posts words carefully and stop putting words in my mouth. I said that religion, to me, is the biggest form of brainwashing. This is a long way from saying that I believe that religion purposefully tries to brainwash people. Although I have heard strong arguments for that very notion. For example, I think TV is one of the biggest forms of brainwashing as well, so would you conclude that I am saying that TV actually tries to brainwash us? NO. Uccisore, I am not twisting anything, you need to pay more attention to my actual words and not what you think is behind them. Yes I previously argued that many religions teach “We as human beings are incapable of truly understanding God, but yet we know the following to be certainties about God…” - this I find to be a paradox and think that either you can know something certain about a thing or you can’t, if you don’t know something certain about a thing it is absurd to talk of it as certain. Because I believe that we cannot know anything certain about anything (everything is always changing) and because if you understand absolutely everything about one thing, it would enfold all knowledge to the universe. Ie. We would all say we know what a chestnut is. But what is a chestnut made of? How does this made of stuff come to be? What is the process? What makes the process? What are the constituents of the making of the process? Sooner or later you get down to atoms of the chestnut, then you get into protons, neutrons, electrons, and then into quarks…but there is much ambiguity surrounding quarks. If you could know everything about a chestnut, I mean everything, you would inevitably know everything about the universe because the chestnut is made of the same foundation as everything else in the universe. So since we can’t know certainty about anything, that includes God. But God, to me, is a human conception which is a thousand times more problematic than the study of atoms. So to me, God as a conception made from thousands of years ago by people in an area prone to creating Gods means that their God does not exist. Atleast not in the way they imagined it thousands of years ago. This is what it is not a twisting of words. It is quite logical to conclude that when you don’t have certainty about a thing, you can’t go around claiming it’s certainty.
Uccisore stated:
I’m not speaking about ALL, I’m talking about anything. There isn’t one thing we KNOW about God for certain. If you read my previous posts carefully you would have noticed that people are uncertain about the meaning of God’s supposed revelations to us and his existence. If he had, I don’t see how any of us could doubt it. The minute you know EVERYTHING about any one thing whether it’s a part of another complex thing or not, you know everything. This isn’t the case and why we can’t know any one thing about God for certain.
What’s your take?